Rate the Kellogg hire

Post by **MikeUMA** » Tue Apr 22, 2008 9:59 pm

Exercise thy vote.

UMassHoops · Post by **UMassHoops** » Tue Apr 22, 2008 10:14 pm

I voted #10, but #2 made me laugh.

Seriously anyone saying they are concerned because DK hasn't been a head coach can't be dismissed, that is a legit concern. But the fit is perfect with the history, the pedigree, the recruiting. We'll see if he has got the coaching magic soon enough, but to me this beats any retread coach we could have brought in, and it takes a little vision so thanks to the AD. DK could potentially take this program further than an out of town guy, so why not take a shot.

MJatUM · Post by **MJatUM** » Tue Apr 22, 2008 10:49 pm

I put a 9, as I see a 10 hire being someone to the tune of Jim Calhoun, Rick Pitino etc..

amazing to see the lowest vote thus far was a 7.

Pretty amazing to see such a popular hire

PS: I hope everyone is fluent in sarcasm (see first sentence).

I did really put a 9 though

ren · Post by **ren** » Tue Apr 22, 2008 10:53 pm

I went with #2 because it was too funny. Besides, the last time he was declared a waste of taxpayer dollars, things worked out OK for him.

-R

classof60 · Post by **classof60** » Wed Apr 23, 2008 6:22 am

put me down for a 10....being from the class of 60, i am computer challenged and can't figure how to cast my vote

good credentials who will not merely be passing through pioneer valley

rjl99 · Post by **rjl99** » Wed Apr 23, 2008 7:38 am

I went with a seven - My excitement for DK ebbs and flows.

MullinsManiac · Post by **MullinsManiac** » Wed Apr 23, 2008 8:53 am

8 ... I'd prefer someone with head coaching experience, but his Cal pedigree, UMass ties, WMass ties and NYC connections offset that.

Plano Minuteman · Post by **Plano Minuteman** » Wed Apr 23, 2008 11:04 am

10 - for several reasons:

1) He's an alum and a huge part of the 90's teams that were so successful.
2) Brings instant credibility given his success at Memphis and other stops.
3) Proven track record recruiting excellent players.
4) West. Mass. will be very excited about this hire, hopefully resulting in better attendance.
5) DDM offense fits our current personnel very well.
6) Bringing Wahlberg the originator of the DDM is the icing on the cake.

WH · Post by WH » Wed Apr 23, 2008 11:18 am

It's all downhill for DK after today. And once he loses a game, watch out for the brass knuckles. People in western Ma are tough! (-:

shovelhd · Post by **shovelhd** » Wed Apr 23, 2008 11:27 am

I gave him an 8, but I hope he goes to 11.

Butter · Post by **Butter** » Wed Apr 23, 2008 1:02 pm

I gave it a 10, and i would have given it 100 if given the option...I was talking to a buddy of mine during the NIT about how with Ford looking elsewhere, how unbelievably smart it would be to bring in DK, I couldn't ask for more...My opinion is, anyone not loving this move is either too young or needs a head check...GREAT HIRE, BEST THAT COULD HAVE HAPPENNED!!!!

LooneyGoon · Post by **LooneyGoon** » Wed Apr 23, 2008 1:15 pm

Great to see a alum coaching the team. 10.

Scott O · Post by **Scott O** » Wed Apr 23, 2008 1:28 pm

What's the matter? People who voted 2-6 too afraid to speak up? C'mon, let's hear it. (ren excluded..)

Jeff93 · Post by **Jeff93** » Thu Apr 24, 2008 8:53 am

I initally stated in the "Who Should Replace Ford" thread before Ford screwed with us (yeah, umm, I was saying how Ford was staying for sure and would be around for several more years...and I was right a-la LSU and PC...but my crystal ball needs new batteries

) That Kellogg would be an ideal choice. I still believe that.

My only oncern is the fan base and the pressure the University will put on DK. I had the same reluctance about Bruiser, and it came true. To this day I believe Bruiser would have been an outstanding caoch at UMass if he had been afforeded another 2 years. But that's all ancient history now.

We need to allow Derek time to build HIS program. He has a good foundation, but expecting an instant return to the 90s success is improbable and setting him up for failure.

What I like best about this pick is it has the possibility of longevity. Assuming everyone plays their roles - fans show up and SUPPORT the program; DK puts together successful teams; the U stands behind DK - this could be the start of something really special. Something like a John Chaney, preferably without the schizophrenic/psychotic undercurrents.

Having been raised in WMass and going to UMass, I can say that there are positions I would accept at UMass for far less money than I could make elsewhere because I love that area and I love the school. I think - actually I am pretty sure - DK has that same feeling. Not to say he would never ever leave for the right deal, but I truly don't think he views UMass as a stepping stone like so many other coaches have.

umass21 · Post by **umass21** » Thu Apr 24, 2008 9:43 am

Times are different now. It was almost a no-win situation to replace Cal. Expectations aren't nearly as high right now. Sure if the team goes 8-17 or something the patience will wear thin, but I think he'll be given time to build his team.

UMassHoops.com

Rate the Kellogg hire

How do you rate the hire of Derek Kellogg?

Rate the Kellogg hire

great hire